Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.

If you haven’t seen The Avengers or any of the other Marvel films – SHIELD is a secret organisation which protects the world from scary stuff. Agent Coulson leads a team of misfits investigating the weird and wonderful to see if they’re dealing with superheroes, or supervillains. If you’ve seen The Avengers… Coulson lives!

Believe it or not, I do actually attempt to be fair and open minded when I watch and review television series. Although I would never claim to be dispassionate about my loves and hates, I do at least try to approach each show and each review with a clinical analysis, working out what I liked and didn’t like, what I respected and appreciated and what I just didn’t get on with and trying to explain those feelings to you, dear reader, to allow you to conclude whether you should or shouldn’t watch the show.

I can’t do that for Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.

I tried. I tried to watch the pilot without succumbing to fangirl glee everytime Coulson appeared, or everytime a character uttered a line of pure Whedon dialogue. But I couldn’t. I don’t actually care whether you watch this show or not, because I love it so much that if you are not sold on it simply by watching the trailer, simply by the phrase “Coulson lives and he has his own television show” then I kind of don’t care what you think.

I adored the pilot. It was everything that Whedon does best. This is a show entirely built around what Whedon has always done – making heroes out of utterly normal people. And he does it how he’s always done it, putting together an ensemble of weird but utterly believable characters, giving them dialogue that jumps off the screen, zigging and zagging the plot in comfortably unpredictable ways and bringing it all together with ruthless efficiency to make all that completely comprehendable in just 45 minutes, without losing sight of style or humour.

If I were to try really hard I could hunt out a few faults. Agent Ward is a bit too straight laced, the speech at the end is maybe a little too topical and obvious (although that doesn’t change the fact it’s true) and the music is a little too “hoorah!”. It’s also possible that the final scene of the pilot is actually the moment the show jumps the shark. Oh and the title is a mouthful to say and even worse to type. But I don’t care.

I love this show. But I love everything Whedon does and says. I love that Clark Gregg (who I have loved since he saved the day on Sports Night and was Agent Casper on The West Wing) must be wondering when he’s going to wake up having gone from a tiny throwaway role in Iron Man to being dead, to being the biggest television star of the new season. I love that Channel 4 is airing it just 3 days after it airs in the states. I love that the first show of the new season I got to see was something with so much heart and so much humour that I feel optimistic for the rest of the schedule around it.

If I’m wrong… I just don’t care.


4 thoughts on “Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.

  1. As long as you’re not one of those cosplay girls hanging around Stark Tower … ;-)

    I’m much the same. I really enjoyed this. I don’t quite understand why some people are so upset that we didn’t see Nick Fury or that we’re (highly) unlikely to see any of the adventures. This is a series about SHIELD, not the Avengers – there’s a clue in the title somewhere – and we should take delight in that.

    Also, Skye .;.. *swoon*

    1. I’d love to get to see an episode of the Avengers on television every week, but it’s just not gonna happen. If the ‘fans’ think the only thing that made the Marvel films work was the big name superheroes and equally big name actors, then I don’t think they’re really fans at all.

      I guess the argument can be made that it’s odd to not see Fury, Black Widow and Hawkeye, given that they’re members of SHIELD, but if Coulson’s team is mostly going to be roaming about in their plane, it’s perfectly reasonable to not see them. I liked the casual references to The Avengers, by mentioning them, it makes it not so much of a ‘thing’.

      1. Agreed. And from a ‘brand management’ point of view, I don’t think it makes any sense to blur the lines between the TV property and the multiple movie franchises we now have. They’re different beasts – and we’re lucky to have two takes on the same universe.

  2. Pingback: The Blacklist: Pilot Review | Narrative Devices

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.